I am currently running most of my stuff from an unraid box using spare parts I have. It seems like I am hitting my limit on it and just want to turn it into a NAS. Micro PCs/USFF are what I am planning on moving stuff to (probably a cluster of 2 for now but might expand later.). Just a few quick questions:

  1. Running arr services on a proxmox cluster to download to a device on the same network. I don’t think there would be any problems but wanted to see what changes need to be done.

  2. Which micro PCs are you running? I am leaving towards HP prodesk or Lenovo 7xx/9xx series around 200 each. I don’t really plan on getting more than 2-3 and don’t run too many things, but would want enough overhead if I switch stuff over to home assistant and windows and Linux VMs if needed.

  3. Any best practices you recommend when starting a Proxmox cluster? I’ve learned over time it’s best to set it up correctly than try to fix stuff when it’s running. I wish I could coach myself from 7 years ago now. Would of saved a lot of headaches lol.

  • phanto@lemmy.caEnglish
    4·
    1 year ago

    Do two NICs. I have a bigger setup, and it’s all running on one LAN, and it is starting to run into problems. Changing to a two network setup from the outset probably would have saved me a lot of grief.

    • Edgarallenpwn@midwest.socialOPEnglish
      1·
      1 year ago

      So dual NIC on each device and set up another lan on my router? Sorry it seems like a dumb question but just want to make sure.

            • FiduciaryOne@lemmy.worldEnglish
              2·
              1 year ago

              Huh, cool, thank you! I’m going to have to look into that. I’d love for some of my containers and VMs to be on a different VLAN from others. I appreciate the correction. 😊

              • DeltaTangoLima@reddrefuge.comEnglish
                2·
                1 year ago

                You still need to do that, but you need the Linux bridge interface to have VLANs defined as well, as the physical switch port that trunks the traffic is going to tag the respective VLANs to/from the Proxmox server and virtual guests.

                So, vmbr1 maps to physical interface enp2s0f0. On vmbr1, I have two VLAN interfaces defined - vmbr1.100 (Proxmox guest VLAN) and vmbr1.60 (Phsyical infrastructure VLAN).

                My Proxmox server has its own address in vlan60, and my Proxmox guests have addresses (and vlan tag) for vlan100.

                The added headfuck (especially at setup) is that I also run an OPNsense VM on Proxmox, and it has its own vlan interfaces defined - essentially virtual interfaces on top of a virtual interface. So, I have:

                • switch trunk port
                  • enp2s0f0 (physical)
                    • vmbr1 (Linux bridge)
                      • vmbr1.60 (Proxmox server interface)
                      • vmbr1.100 (Proxmox VLAN interface)
                        • virtual guest nic (w/ vlan tag and IP address)
                      • vtnet1 (OPNsense “physical” nic, but actually virtual)
                        • vtnet1_vlan[xxx] (OPNsense virtual nic per vlan)

                All virtual guests default route via OPNsense’s IP address in vlan100, which maps to OPNsense virtual interface vtnet1_vlan100.

                Like I said, it’s a headfuck when you first set it up. Interface-ception.

                The only unnecessary bit in my setup is that my Proxmox server also has an IP address in vlan100 (via vmbr1.100). I had it there when I originally thought I’d use Proxmox firewalling as well, to effectively create a zero trust network for my Proxmox cluster. But, for me, that would’ve been overkill.

        • stown@sedd.it
          English
          2·
          1 year ago

          Security. Keeping publicly accessible and locally accessible on different networks.

          • DeltaTangoLima@reddrefuge.comEnglish
            2·
            1 year ago

            Hmmm - not really any more. I have everything on the same VLAN, with publicly accessible services sitting behind nginx reverse proxy (using Authelia and 2FA).

            The real separation I have is the separate physical interface I use for WAN connectivity to my virtualised firewall/router - OPNsense. But I could also easily achieve that with VLANs on my switch, if I only had a single interface.

            The days of physical DMZs are almost gone - virtualisation has mostly superseded them. Not saying they’re not still a good idea, just less of an explicit requirement nowadays.

        • PlasterAnalyst@kbin.social
          1·
          1 year ago

          You want to have at least 3 if you’re going to do that. I usually use the one on the mobo for all the other services and management. Then a dedicated port for lan and wan on a separate nic.

        • DeltaTangoLima@reddrefuge.comEnglish
          1·
          1 year ago

          This is exactly my setup on one of my Proxmox servers - a second NIC connected as my WAN adapter to my fibre internet. OPNsense firewall/router uses it.