I sail the high seas of the Lemmyverse, posting snarky + Lefty comments

  • 0 Posts
  • 34 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: May 7th, 2023

help-circle

  • Ahhh, of course, we are going to reach for the ā€œAnti-Zionism = Anti- Semitismā€ defense. For the record, I make common cause with any Jewish people who oppose colonialism and genocide, like these honest and noble folks: https://www.jewishvoiceforpeace.org/

    Interesting, I wonder what happened immediately before the state of Israel declared Independence? Funny how you and the other occupiers never want to talk about the Nakba. Funny how you want to talk about declaring independence but not about displacing hundreds of thousands and destroying or colonizing hundreds of villages and towns.

    How about this: return all the land that was taken in the Nakba, then we can stop talking about the destruction of the occupier state. Is that civil and fair enough for you? Or was it always about stealing the land from the beginning?



  • assault with intent to annihilate

    So weā€™re just making up serious sounding phrases to try and balance the scales? Which side is bulldozing houses and stealing land? Which side is practicing brutal apartheid? Which side FUCKING BOMBS SCHOOLS AND HOSPITALS?

    Jesus fucking Christ get outside of your media bubble every once in awhile.

    I suspect that you canā€™t because you have built a comfortable occupier existence for yourself, so you canā€™t look at the pile of bodies forming the foundation of your existence.


  • Now it seems weā€™ve reached a ā€œverbal argumentā€ where itā€™s just an argument over definitions, which Iā€™m not interested in.

    This is where Iā€™m personally going to leave this:

    Some people see the 70 -year genocide of the Palestinians as an unspeakable atrocity that plainly justifies violent and non-violent resistance.

    Some people want to center the fears of the occupiers in the discussion, and use that to throw up their hands and shut down any action or solution that isnā€™t on the occupiersā€™ terms.


  • Again, this is an essential distinction. States are not peoples. A national group is the people of a state, not the state itself.

    The axis states ceased to exist after world war II. Despite gratuitous bombing by allied forces, the peoples of the states continue to exist, and largely inhabit the same territory.

    Seemingly by your argument, land can be seized, people expelled, war crimes committed, but if you have created a state, it would be inherently wrong to dislodge you. I personally donā€™t regard states as a magic blanket that rules out decolonization by definition.






  • The solution is not enabling the settlers and ultra-orthodox.

    Another option is destroying / blockading the last functioning Zionist port, I expect that will get results real quick. They have decided to build their civilization inspired by the worst excesses of the West, so it will quickly collapse in the absence of endless imports.

    Once you turn the grim logic of destroying houses and resource starvation back on the occupiers, you donā€™t have to keep pretending that they are mysterious, incomprehensible, and immovable.




  • I mean, yea. You think the world is some happy go lucky place where people donā€™t fight each other?

    Ummā€¦lol no. I think the world is run by military forces and their obedient governments.

    The US dropped two nuclear bombs on civilians in Japan to end a war quickly

    Vaporize civilians for peace!

    theyā€™d kill civilians again in a heartbeat if it was beneficial to America

    If by America you mean imperial warmaking and profits then yes, ā€œtheyā€ have, would, and will continue.

    The number of civilians that died from the American invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan after 9/11 shows that very clearly. The current Palestinian death toll is less than 10% of that 20 year conflict, and it was done by Americans directly

    This point is really confusing butā€¦yay America?

    Cuba is being used as a pawn by other countries to threaten the US

    Wow what a take. Other countries support Cuba, so the USA gets to perpetuate invasions, assassination attempts, terrorism and eternal economic warfare. The Cubans have no autonomy but also they brought this on themselves.