Unfortunately, casting from potato to carrot is a narrowing conversion so your new carrot will lose some properties

It really is amazing tho how much they managed to fuck New n Tasty up compared to the original.

I know, right? Talk about first world issues

This isn’t possible. Every time I tried that it leaves behind 2 nasty & sharp plastic prongs. I’ve found no way to avoid that. And they can’t even be removed, I tried with pliers and a lighter and some sharp plastic spikes will inevitably remain.